Page 4 of 5

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 14 Mar 2012, 20:35
by skiflyer11
greex1 wrote:
Rajmek1233 wrote:greex

235 oberstdorf?? o.O

I think there is a possible jump max 230
:) I ask because in BM record is 215, and can jump 223
yes but thats according to the real lines :)

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 10:24
by Jussi Koskela
Jussi Koskela wrote: The first question is if the range of lines should be different in summer/winter modes. Different ranges might make it difficult to estimate how far you are jumping. Some hills are also missing the lines after HS in the plastic covering.

The second question is whether the real patterns should be replicated for each hill. The markings are not always as clear as they are currently in DSJ4 (e.g. Lahti), so it's a tradeoff between reality and clarity.
I am looking forward to hear more opinions on these.

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 11:13
by skiflyer11
I think you should use the original lines from all hills :)
Especially at lahti and kuusamo

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 12:16
by Pavlokox
Jussi Koskela wrote:
Jussi Koskela wrote: The first question is if the range of lines should be different in summer/winter modes. Different ranges might make it difficult to estimate how far you are jumping. Some hills are also missing the lines after HS in the plastic covering.

The second question is whether the real patterns should be replicated for each hill. The markings are not always as clear as they are currently in DSJ4 (e.g. Lahti), so it's a tradeoff between reality and clarity.
I am looking forward to hear more opinions on these.
Ad.1
In my opinion lines should be different (summer/winter). Players know each hill well and it wouldn't disturb them.

Ad.2
To my mind a scheme of lines on each hill should be like in real, but their clarity can be improved, let mi say: as if hill has been prepared for more important competition for example World Championships.

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 13:51
by Jussi Koskela
So, maybe correct range of lines in the next version and custom styles in the following. Custom styles requires a lot more work.

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 14:30
by nanucha
Pavlokox wrote:
Jussi Koskela wrote:
Jussi Koskela wrote: The first question is if the range of lines should be different in summer/winter modes. Different ranges might make it difficult to estimate how far you are jumping. Some hills are also missing the lines after HS in the plastic covering.

The second question is whether the real patterns should be replicated for each hill. The markings are not always as clear as they are currently in DSJ4 (e.g. Lahti), so it's a tradeoff between reality and clarity.
I am looking forward to hear more opinions on these.
Ad.1
In my opinion lines should be different (summer/winter). Players know each hill well and it wouldn't disturb them.

Ad.2
To my mind a scheme of lines on each hill should be like in real, but their clarity can be improved, let mi say: as if hill has been prepared for more important competition for example World Championships.

I agree with Pavlokox

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 14:34
by nanucha
Jussi Koskela wrote:So, maybe correct range of lines in the next version and custom styles in the following. Custom styles requires a lot more work.
What do you mean by "custom styles" ?

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 14:49
by Jussi Koskela
nanucha wrote:
Jussi Koskela wrote:So, maybe correct range of lines in the next version and custom styles in the following. Custom styles requires a lot more work.
What do you mean by "custom styles" ?
Customized (=real) style of lines for each hill.

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 15:09
by Metsi
Jussi Koskela wrote:
nanucha wrote:
Jussi Koskela wrote:So, maybe correct range of lines in the next version and custom styles in the following. Custom styles requires a lot more work.
What do you mean by "custom styles" ?
Customized (=real) style of lines for each hill.
It depends on how much work do you need to put in customizing the lines on each hill.
If it would talke a lot of time i think we could deal with the same lines at every hill :)

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 16:28
by nanucha
so... as I say
nanucha wrote:but...

as we see on real photo this lines are the same (the same lenght) but in dsj are getting longer......and longer...

Lillehammer, for example: Image

there are exactly the same length

Also in Gapa:
Image

In Villach are also the same:
Image


Lahti? This is strange:
Image

Kusamo is geious, this color :D :
Image

Zakopane:
Image


In Sapporo they are so longer and longer:
Image

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 21:10
by bulwa11
well I dont really care for summer that much, but in future versions correct lines for winter hills would be awesome :)

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 21:46
by Jussi Koskela
bulwa11 wrote:well I dont really care for summer that much, but in future versions correct lines for winter hills would be awesome :)
How do you define what is "correct"? After all, the lines can be laid different way for each competition.

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 21:51
by Bartek Palewicz
Jussi Koskela wrote:
bulwa11 wrote:well I dont really care for summer that much, but in future versions correct lines for winter hills would be awesome :)
How do you define what is "correct"? After all, the lines can be laid different way for each competition.
I think is talking about lines after HS in winter, just like here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gvrcv1jf ... AAAAAAAQAA

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 15 Mar 2012, 23:29
by bulwa11
correct as in "like in real life" during world cup competitions. Although when I think about it its pretty similar in all hills: full lines / short lines until the K point. Then a red line on a K point and on the HS point and two lines connecting the K and HS lines. And a few short lines after the HS point. The differences are small on different hills but I as a detail kind of guy notice those ;)
It be pretty cool to have custom lines for different hills but it shouldn't be on top of the list. But in some future version - yes :)

Re: Lines after HS

Posted: 16 Mar 2012, 00:18
by pietrek
Wouldn't it be possible to make a "lines editor"? Then we could do just what we want. And i agree, custom lines for every hill - that's an awesome idea. What about deleting red K and HS marks in training mode?? Just leave the lines in the interval of 10 meters like this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=icI9VHGcs68